Our story

Cooking up The New neighborhood pizzeria.

We are local friends with families who wanted to build a better neighborhood pizzeria. Not to reinvent it, just to do it right: great food made from scratch, genuine hospitality, and a warm place to enjoy it, in the heart of Cherry Hill.

More than a pizza shop, we wanted a gathering place for the community we love, somewhere friends and family can pull up a table, stay a while, and eat really well. Daniel's wife has celiac disease, so an allergen-aware kitchen was part of the plan from the start.

That is what pizza for everyone means to us: everyone at the table eats well. We make it all here, and we show up for the neighborhood with Dine and Donate nights and community partners around Cherry Hill. Come in and bring the whole table.

Barclay Pies founders TJ Hunton and Daniel Romero at the shop
Order Online